Case details

Court: ca7
Docket #: 12-3388
Case Name: Clean Water Action Council of, et al v. EPA, et al
PACER case #: 12-3388
Date filed: 2012-10-17
Date terminated: 2014-08-29

Documents

Date Filed Document # Attachment # Short Description Long Description Upload date SHA1 hash
2012-10-17 1 0 Petition for Review docketed with proof of service, pursuant to FRAP 15(c). Fee due. Agency record or certified list due by 11/26/2012. Fee or IFP forms due on 10/31/2012 for Petitioners Clean Water Action Council of Northeastern Wisconsin, Incorporated and Midwest Environmental Defense Center, Incorporated. [1] [6435916] [12-3388] (FP)
1 1 Petition for Review Docketed 2013-10-04 14:57:05 d49148196f77232f955b58881c7d7ae04665cbdc
1 2 Attorney / Party Notice of Docketing
1 3 Agency Fee Letter
1 4 Agency Cover Letter
2012-10-29 2 0 Disclosure Statement filed by Attorney David Bender for Petitioners Clean Water Action Council of Northeastern Wisconsin, Incorporated and Midwest Environmental Defense Center, Incorporated. [2] [6438829] [12-3388] (Bender, David)
2012-11-13 3 0 Disclosure Statement filed by Attorney Michelle L. Jacobs for Georgia-Pacific Consumer Products LP. [3] [6442191] [12-3388] (Jacobs, Michelle)
2012-11-13 4 0 Appearance form filed by Attorney Dustin J. Maghamfar for Respondents EPA and Lisa P. Jackson. [4] [6442510] [12-3388]--[Edited 11/13/2012 by AM to reflect termination of attorneys Cirino and Mathur and the addition of attorney Maghamfar] (Maghamfar, Dustin)
2012-11-14 5 0 Filed Non-Party Unopposed Motion to Intervene by Georgia-Pacific Consumer Products LP. [6442646] [12-3388] (Jacobs, Michelle)
2012-11-16 6 0 Motion filed by Respondents EPA and Lisa P. Jackson to extend time to file the Administrative Record. [6] [6443525] [12-3388] (Maghamfar, Dustin)
2012-11-16 7 0 Order issued GRANTING motion to extend time to file the agency record. [6] The respondents shall file the certified administrative record by 12/17/2012. CMD [7] [6443599] [7] [6443599] [12-3388] (CD)
2012-11-19 8 0 Disclosure Statement filed by Attorney Michelle L. Jacobs for Not Party Georgia-Pacific Consumer Products LP. [8] [6443879] [12-3388] (Jacobs, Michelle)
2012-11-20 9 0 Order issued GRANTING Unopposed Motion to Intervene of Georgia-pacific Consumer Products LP. Georgia-Pacific Consumer Products LP is granted leave to participate as an intervening respondent. [5] SCR [9] [6444225] [12-3388] (AD)
2012-12-17 10 0 Filed Notice of Filing Certified Index to the Administrative Record by Respondents EPA and Lisa P. Jackson. [10] [6450607] [12-3388] (Maghamfar, Dustin)
2013-01-14 12 0 Disclosure Statement filed by Attorney Jordan Hemaidan for Intervening Respondent Georgia-Pacific Consumer Products LP. [12] [6456326] [12-3388]--[Edited 01/14/2013 by FP to reflect that atty. Hemaidan is added to the docket.] (Hemaidan, Jordan)
2013-01-14 13 0 Joint motion filed by Intervening Respondent Georgia-Pacific Consumer Products LP, Not Party Georgia-Pacific Consumer Products LP, Petitioners Clean Water Action Council of Northeastern Wisconsin, Incorporated, Midwest Environmental Defense Center, Incorporated and Respondents EPA and Lisa P. Jackson Establish briefing Schedule and Delayed Filing of Joint Appendix. [13] [6456387] [12-3388] (Bender, David)
2013-01-16 14 0 Order issued GRANTING motion to establish the briefing schedule. Briefing shall proceed as follows: [13] 1. Agency brief #1 due on or before 02/11/2013 for Petitioners Clean Water Action Council of Northeastern Wisconsin, Incorporated and Midwest Environmental Defense Center, Incorporated. 2. Agency brief #2 due on or before 04/12/2013 for Respondents Environmental Protection Agency and Lisa P. Jackson. 3. Intervenor brief due on 04/26/2013 for Intervening Respondent Georgia-Pacific Consumer Products LP. 4. Agency brief #3, if any, is due on or before 05/10/2013 for Petitioners Clean Water Action Council of Northeastern Wisconsin, Incorporated and Midwest Environmental Defense Center, Incorporated. The parties are permitted to file a Deferred Joint Appendix. This appendix is due on or before May 24, 2013. See Fed. R. App. P. 30(c). Final briefs referencing the Deferred Joint Appendix, see Fed. R. App. P. 30(c)(2)(B), and paper copies of the parties' briefs are due on or before June 7, 2013. [13] SCR [14] [6457259] [12-3388] (CD)
2013-01-24 15 0 Motion filed by Intervening Respondent Georgia-Pacific Consumer Products LP to withdraw as counsel [15] [6459211] [12-3388] (Jacobs, Michelle)
2013-01-25 16 0 Order issued GRANTING motion to withdraw as counsel. Attorney Michelle L. Jacobs may withdraw from further involvement in this matter. The clerk shall modify the docket accordingly. [15] CMD [16] [6459302] [12-3388] (CD)
2013-02-11 17 0 Submitted appellant brief by David Bender for Petitioners Clean Water Action Council of Northeastern Wisconsin, Incorporated and Midwest Environmental Defense Center, Incorporated. [17] [6463456] [12-3388] (Bender, David)
2013-02-11 18 0 Agency #1 brief filed by Petitioners Clean Water Action Council of Northeastern Wisconsin, Incorporated and Midwest Environmental Defense Center, Incorporated. Paper copies due on 02/19/2013 Electronically Transmitted. [6463498] [12-3388] (LJ) 2013-10-04 14:57:22 1d410fd59d6fcbc694df21ade431af92b7be6243
2013-04-02 19 0 Motion filed by Respondents EPA and Lisa P. Jackson to extend time to file agency 2 brief. [19] [6475687] [12-3388] (Maghamfar, Dustin)
2013-04-02 20 0 Order issued GRANTING Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Respondents’ Answering Brief, and briefing will proceed as follows: The respondents’ brief is due May 3, 2013. The intervenor’s brief is due May 17, 2013. The petitioners’ joint reply brief, if any, is due May 31, 2013. The Deferred Joint Appendix is due on or before June 14, 2013. Final briefs referencing the Deferred Joint Appendix and paper copies of the parties’ briefs are due on or before June 28, 2013. [19] JKL [20] [6475780] [12-3388] (AD)
2013-04-26 21 0 Filed Notice to Substitute Respondent by Respondents EPA and Lisa P. Jackson. [21] [6481853] [12-3388] (Maghamfar, Dustin)
2013-05-03 22 0 Submitted agency 2 brief by Dustin J. Maghamfar for Respondents EPA and Lisa P. Jackson. [22] [6483903] [12-3388] (Maghamfar, Dustin) 2013-10-11 14:33:32 c15da58ef14edc5a4e0e619c933b239d467ae7e8
2013-05-03 23 0 Agency #2 brief filed by Respondents EPA and Lisa P. Jackson. Electronically Transmitted. [6484032] [12-3388] (RT)
2013-05-17 24 0 Submitted intervenor brief by Jordan Hemaidan for Intervening Respondent Georgia-Pacific Consumer Products LP. [24] [6487179] [12-3388] (Hemaidan, Jordan) 2014-08-30 12:35:59 deffb78bfdc0ca2029ee5891c49370982e0509b5
2013-05-17 25 0 Intervenor brief filed by Intervening Respondent Georgia-Pacific Consumer Products LP. Electronically Transmitted. [25] [6487193] [12-3388] (BS)
2013-05-31 26 0 Submitted appellant reply brief by David Bender for Petitioners Clean Water Action Council of Northeastern Wisconsin, Incorporated and Midwest Environmental Defense Center, Incorporated. [26] [6490299] [12-3388] (Bender, David) 2014-08-30 12:39:56 b71a29d3d92a3467b11e555711499accda9162cb
2013-05-31 27 0 Agency #3 brief filed by Petitioners Clean Water Action Council of Northeastern Wisconsin, Incorporated and Midwest Environmental Defense Center, Incorporated. Paper copies due on 06/10/2013 Electronically Transmitted. [6490319] [12-3388] (RS)
2013-06-14 28 0 Submitted Joint Appendix by David Bender for Petitioners Clean Water Action Council of Northeastern Wisconsin, Incorporated and Midwest Environmental Defense Center, Incorporated. [28] [6493630] [12-3388] (Bender, David)
2013-06-14 29 0 Filed Deferred Appendix by Petitioners Clean Water Action Council of Northeastern Wisconsin, Incorporated and Midwest Environmental Defense Center, Incorporated. [29] [6493687] Paper copies due on 06/21/2013. [12-3388] (BS)
2013-06-19 30 0 Submitted intervenor brief by Jordan Hemaidan for Intervening Respondent Georgia-Pacific Consumer Products LP. [30] [6494646] [12-3388] (Hemaidan, Jordan)
2013-06-19 31 0 Final Intervenor brief filed by Intervening Respondent Georgia-Pacific Consumer Products LP. Electronically Transmitted. Paper copies due on 6/28/13. [31] [6494705] [12-3388] (AB) 2013-10-04 14:59:20 80cf42a2f48f0cb821624b966887c52857d91fd4
2013-06-21 32 0 Submitted agency 2 brief by Dustin J. Maghamfar for Respondents EPA and Lisa P. Jackson. [32] [6494988] [12-3388] (Maghamfar, Dustin)
2013-06-21 33 0 Agency #2 brief filed by Respondents EPA and Lisa P. Jackson. Paper copies due on 06/28/2013 Electronically Transmitted. [6495062] [12-3388]--[Edited 06/25/2013 by CD to reflect STRICKEN per the court's order dated 6/25/2013.] (RT)
2013-06-25 34 0 Order: Respondents' brief is STRICKEN. Respondents must file a new brief, which contains a jurisdictional statement that complies with all the requirements of Circuit Rule 28(b), and if petitioners' jurisdictional statement is not complete and correct, Circuit Rule 28(a) also. Counsel for respondents are reminded that they may not change any other portion of the brief. Agency brief #2 due on or before 07/02/2013 for Respondents Environmental Protection Agency and Lisa P. Jackson. (See order for further details). DW [34] [6495911] [12-3388] (CD)
2013-06-25 35 0 Submitted appellant brief by David Bender for Petitioners Clean Water Action Council of Northeastern Wisconsin, Incorporated and Midwest Environmental Defense Center, Incorporated. [35] [6496010] [12-3388] (Bender, David)
2013-06-25 36 0 Submitted appellant reply brief by David Bender for Petitioners Clean Water Action Council of Northeastern Wisconsin, Incorporated and Midwest Environmental Defense Center, Incorporated. [36] [6496012] [12-3388] (Bender, David) 2013-10-04 15:00:26 2fb685c84af882b17de78361c7261549758655eb
2013-06-25 37 0 Final Agency #1 brief filed by Petitioners Clean Water Action Council of Northeastern Wisconsin, Incorporated and Midwest Environmental Defense Center, Incorporated. Electronically Transmitted. [37] [6496067] [12-3388]--[Edited 06/26/2013 by RS] (RS)
2013-06-25 38 0 Final Agency #3 brief filed by Petitioners Clean Water Action Council of Northeastern Wisconsin, Incorporated and Midwest Environmental Defense Center, Incorporated. Paper copies due on 07/03/2013 Electronically Transmitted. [6496237] [12-3388] (GW)
2013-07-02 39 0 Submitted agency 2 brief by Dustin J. Maghamfar for Respondents EPA and Lisa P. Jackson. [39] [6497766] [12-3388] (Maghamfar, Dustin)
2013-07-02 40 0 CORRECTED Agency #2 brief filed by Respondent EPA and Lisa P. Jackson. Paper copies due on 07/09/2013 Electronically Transmitted. [6497801] [12-3388] (LJ)
2013-07-08 41 0 NOTICE: Attorney Mr. David C. Bender for Petitioners Clean Water Action Council of Northeastern Wisconsin, Incorporated and Midwest Environmental Defense Center, Incorporated will not be available for oral argument 7/29/13, 7/30/13, 7/31/13, 8/1/13, 8/2/13, 8/5/13, 8/6/13, 8/7/13, 8/8/13. 8/9/13, 9/30/13, 10/1/13. 10/2/13, 10/3/13, 10/4/13, 10/7/13, 10/28/13, 10/29/13, 10/30/13, 10/31/13, 11/1/13, 11/4/13, 11/5/13, 11/6/13, 11/7/13, 11/8/13. [41] [6498662] [12-3388] (Bender, David)
2013-07-09 42 0 NOTICE: Atty. Jordan Hemaidan for Intervening Respondent Georgia-Pacific Consumer Products LP is not available for oral argument 8/12/13 thru 8/23/13, 10/14/13 thru 10/18/13, 11/11/13 thru 11/15/13, 12/16/13 thru 12/31/13. [42] [6498841] [12-3388] --[Edited 07/09/2013 by AB] (Hemaidan, Jordan)
2013-07-22 43 0 NOTICE: Attorney Mr. Dustin J. Maghamfar for Respondents EPA and Lisa P. Jackson will not be available for oral argument September 26-27 & November 1-22, 2013. [43] [6502085] [12-3388] (Maghamfar, Dustin)
2013-08-05 44 0 Argument set for Monday, September 23, 2013, at 11:00 a.m. at the University of Wisconsin Law School, 975 Bascom Mall, Room 2260, Madison, WI. Oral argument time will be limited to: 20 minutes to the Petitioners and 20 minutes to the Respondents and Intervening Respondent. [44] [6505545] [12-3388] (AB)
2013-09-13 46 0 Received argument confirmation from Jordan J. Hemaidan for Intervening Respondent Georgia-Pacific Consumer Products LP. [46] [6514901] [12-3388] (Hemaidan, Jordan)
2013-09-13 47 0 Received argument confirmation from Dustin J. Maghamfar for Respondents EPA and Gina McCarthy. [47] [6514903] [12-3388] (Maghamfar, Dustin)
2013-09-13 48 0 Received argument confirmation from David Bender for Petitioners Clean Water Action Council of Northeastern Wisconsin, Incorporated and Midwest Environmental Defense Center, Incorporated. [48] [6514974] [12-3388] (Bender, David)
2014-05-13 51 0 Filed Respondents EPA and Gina McCarthy Citation of Additional Authority, per Circuit Rule 28(e). Argument set for: 09/23/2013. [51] [6575191] [12-3388] (Maghamfar, Dustin)
2014-08-29 52 0 Filed opinion of the court by Judge Easterbrook. The petition for review is DENIED. Frank H. Easterbrook, Circuit Judge; Diane S. Sykes, Circuit Judge and John Daniel Tinder, Circuit Judge. [52] [6602088] [12-3388] (AD)
2014-08-29 53 0 ORDER: Final judgment filed per opinion. With costs: yes. [53] [6602090] [12-3388] (AD)